"9" Review

Sean Dollentas • August 6, 2025

Title: 9

Director: Shane Acker

Starring: Elijah Wood, John C. Reilly, Jennifer Connelly, Christopher Plummer, Crispin Glover, Martin Landau, Fred Tatasciore

We’ve had a very good year for animation. Pixar wowed us again with their brilliance, Miyazaki reminded us what it was to have the heart of a child, and “Coraline” was an acid trip into Henry Sellicks mind (someplace you don’t always want to be). Now we have “9,” a post-apocalyptic cartoon that is meant for adults. And when I say adults I truly mean it. Appropriately rated PG-13, the movie is a full length adaptation of a short film that was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Animated Short. The storyline revolves around a doll creature named 9, who comes alive one day to discover the world is in ruins and machines rule the land. He runs into other dolls who are numbered just like him.

A creature with goggles crawls, holding a glowing staff, as a building explodes in the background.

These dolls all fill him in on what’s happened in the world. Some want to fight the machines while others want to hide. The original short was directed by Shane Acker who returns as director here. He is joined by producer Tim Burton who was impressed by the short and - more importantly - is the only man in Hollywood with the power to help sell a movie like this. Truly I’m impressed the film got made at all. It’s a dark movie that is not made for kids, it’s something that does not look cute, and these movies are difficult to sell. Even “Titan A.E.” failed to deliver at the box office and that movie WAS suitable for family audiences! Will the teens and adults pay to see this?

Two ragdoll figures exchange glowing orbs in a dim, surreal setting.

Who knows? I’m certain Focus Features has similar concerns. Why else would they hire Christopher Plummer (1), Martin Laundau (2), John C. Riley (5), Crispin Glover (6), Jennifer Connelly (7), Fred Tatasciore (8), and Elijah Wood (9) for reasons other then that they can at least sell the actors (by the way: 3 & 4 are silent characters). In fact, the movie might have been more interesting if the characters had been silent (with the exception of the doctor, who has to deliver the obligatory “what the heck happened to Earth” speech). Visually this film delivers on every conceivable level. The world is creative and very bleak. We’ve certainly never seen American animation create a world this hostile before.

A wooden figure interacts with a menacing skeletal cat in a dark cave.

That’s also where the praise is going to end though because the story is pretty thin and the characters unrelateable. Considering all the bad things happen as a result of the protagonist being an idiot, it’s amazing the film didn’t get on my nerves sooner. If all this movie had was the script I’d have tossed it before the second act. Thanks to the visuals I was fairly engaged throughout the film. Still...that’s not really a recommendation. Was I ever bored? No, but then, it also didn’t really leave much of a past-the-parking lot experience for me either.

Black star on white background.
Black star on white background.
Black star on a white background.
Black star on white background.
Black star shape, partially cut off on the left side.

4.5  Rating


White background.

Share this page with fellow film lovers on your favorite social media platform and let’s keep the movie talk going!

Recent Posts

Airplane flying through dark storm clouds overhead
By Kevin Rodriguez September 16, 2026
A gripping look at the events aboard United Flight 93, iCritic's review explores how Greengrass's film powerfully captures the fear, courage, and chaos of 9/11.
Dimly lit lounge with neon arch lights, people seated at tables, and a bright windowed area on the left.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 11, 2026
Disney’s Star Wars hotel promised an immersive revolution but became a costly failure—revealing the hubris behind one of Disney’s biggest miscalculations in history.
Two men face off in a dry field; one raises a hand while holding a shotgun.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 9, 2026
Does the Coen brothers' "No Country for Old Men" live up to its massive hype? Read our full review exploring Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin, and that shocking ending.
Superhero team standing amid rubble, with Captain America, Iron Man, Hulk, Thor and others ready for battle
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Does Marvel's epic team-up live up to the hype? Read iCritic's full review of "The Avengers" exploring Joss Whedon's witty dialogue, Loki, and non-stop action.
Menacing black robot head with glowing red eyes against a cloudy sky
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Overstuffed action and zero stakes make "Avengers: Age of Ultron" a major disappointment. Read iCritic's (borderline frustrated) review of Joss Whedon's MCU sequel.
Thanos in gold armor raises his gauntlet amid a fiery battle scene
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Is "Avengers: Infinity War" a true cinematic epic or half a movie? Read our full unrated review exploring Josh Brolin's Thanos and Marvel's boldest cliffhanger.
Person crouches in a dim teal-lit industrial room, working with equipment amid cables and machinery.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
It all comes together in ‘Avengers: Endgame,’ as Marvel delivers an emotional, action-packed culmination of more than a decade of storytelling in the popular MCU.
Person holding Captain America shield outdoors on a grassy field with trees in the background
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
“Captain America: Brave New World” struggles to find its footing, delivering a disappointing Marvel sequel that feels more ordinary than brave, bold, or new.
Close-up of a man’s face beside a glowing silhouetted figure on a dark orange background
By Kevin Rodriguez August 27, 2026
More than just an iconic twist: Read iCritic's review of "The Sixth Sense" to see why Bruce Willis & Haley Joel Osment's ghost story remains a heartbreaking classic
Black-and-white portrait of a stern-faced person with dramatic spiky hair against a dark background
By Kevin Rodriguez August 27, 2026
Bizarre, hypnotic, and morbidly beautiful: Read iCritic's 3.5-star review of David Lynch's directorial debut "Eraserhead" and its lasting surreal horror legacy.
Airplane flying through dark storm clouds overhead
By Kevin Rodriguez September 16, 2026
A gripping look at the events aboard United Flight 93, iCritic's review explores how Greengrass's film powerfully captures the fear, courage, and chaos of 9/11.
Dimly lit lounge with neon arch lights, people seated at tables, and a bright windowed area on the left.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 11, 2026
Disney’s Star Wars hotel promised an immersive revolution but became a costly failure—revealing the hubris behind one of Disney’s biggest miscalculations in history.
Two men face off in a dry field; one raises a hand while holding a shotgun.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 9, 2026
Does the Coen brothers' "No Country for Old Men" live up to its massive hype? Read our full review exploring Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin, and that shocking ending.
Superhero team standing amid rubble, with Captain America, Iron Man, Hulk, Thor and others ready for battle
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Does Marvel's epic team-up live up to the hype? Read iCritic's full review of "The Avengers" exploring Joss Whedon's witty dialogue, Loki, and non-stop action.
Menacing black robot head with glowing red eyes against a cloudy sky
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Overstuffed action and zero stakes make "Avengers: Age of Ultron" a major disappointment. Read iCritic's (borderline frustrated) review of Joss Whedon's MCU sequel.
Thanos in gold armor raises his gauntlet amid a fiery battle scene
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Is "Avengers: Infinity War" a true cinematic epic or half a movie? Read our full unrated review exploring Josh Brolin's Thanos and Marvel's boldest cliffhanger.
Person crouches in a dim teal-lit industrial room, working with equipment amid cables and machinery.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
It all comes together in ‘Avengers: Endgame,’ as Marvel delivers an emotional, action-packed culmination of more than a decade of storytelling in the popular MCU.
Person holding Captain America shield outdoors on a grassy field with trees in the background
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
“Captain America: Brave New World” struggles to find its footing, delivering a disappointing Marvel sequel that feels more ordinary than brave, bold, or new.
Close-up of a man’s face beside a glowing silhouetted figure on a dark orange background
By Kevin Rodriguez August 27, 2026
More than just an iconic twist: Read iCritic's review of "The Sixth Sense" to see why Bruce Willis & Haley Joel Osment's ghost story remains a heartbreaking classic
Black-and-white portrait of a stern-faced person with dramatic spiky hair against a dark background
By Kevin Rodriguez August 27, 2026
Bizarre, hypnotic, and morbidly beautiful: Read iCritic's 3.5-star review of David Lynch's directorial debut "Eraserhead" and its lasting surreal horror legacy.
Show More