Home is Lost in "Fatherland"
Kevin Rodriguez • November 15, 2026
Title: Fatherland
Director: Paweł Pawlikowski
Starring: Sandra Hüller, Hanns Zischler
Genre: Drama
Studio: MUBI
Rating: Not Rated
Recently, I saw a movie Peter Berg directed:
The Mosquito Bowl was based on the true story of football players who volunteered to join the Marines after the attack on Pearl Harbor and ultimately played a football game in Okinawa. While the film was competently made and there wasn’t anything inherently wrong with it, I felt the grisly battle sequences had been done before, and there wasn’t really enough new, interesting material to justify its existence. Now, two days later, I am watching Fatherland, directed by Paweł Pawlikowski. His previous film was
Cold War, which told the story of two people falling in love when the world seemed to be falling apart.

That film was lovely and bleak at the same time, and netted the director an Oscar nomination for Best Director (as well as a spot on my Top 10 Best Films of the Year list). Now, he has returned with
Fatherland, a biographical film about German author Thomas Mann (Hanns Zischler), who left Germany when the Nazis invaded Poland, but has returned on a speaking tour now that the war is over. He has won the Nobel Prize in Literature, and he is going from country to country to pontificate on the virtues of peace. His daughter, Erika Mann (Sandra Hüller), joins him, but is secretly skeptical of his ability to truly change the minds of people. In her view, going to different countries and collecting accolades from people who did atrocious things during the war is more about his ego than the greater good.
It doesn’t help that during this trip, her brother Klaus commits suicide as a result of his disappointment with Germany, and she starts to wonder if humanity can ever be redeemed. In fact, when they are asked where home is, Thomas answers bleakly, “Currently, my house is in California. As for where my heart is… I am unsure.” Some view him as a traitor who should have stayed in Germany and spoken out against the Nazi regime. Had he stayed, though, there was a plausible chance he would not be alive to speak to anyone about anything. As the two travel the country that they once called home, a quiet sense of loss hangs over them, and the question of whether they can truly return is an answer they seek, yet may not be able to receive.
All right, so this isn’t exactly a war movie in the same vein as
The Mosquito Bowl. There are no battle scenes, no guns are drawn, and the movie doesn’t even last a full hour and a half. Yet
Fatherland captivates due to a quiet sadness that can only be felt while watching it. When I watch
The Mosquito Bowl, I feel like I am watching an imitation of better war movies. When I watch
Fatherland, I feel like I am walking alongside two people whose lives were dramatically changed by the war, and are finding themselves at a crossroads with how to deal with those changes. The war is over… but can they forgive their country for what it did? Did they leave for the greater good, or just to save their own skin? The novels Thomas Mann wrote were acclaimed and widely read, but did they change minds or make society a better place?
These are the questions that Pawlikowski asks and ponders, and he does so in a way that is brief, emotional, and longing. With
Ida, he directed a movie where a nun is asked to look outside of the church for personal answers the congregation can’t help her with. In
Cold War, two lovers face a daunting life where happiness may always be at arm's length. Now, with
Fatherland, Pawlikowski is following two people who were wronged by the world, survived the worst, and yet don’t know where to go from here. Even at a brief 82 minutes, that is a journey worth taking, and Pawlikowski has become one of the best directors making movies about human contemplation in the world.
Recent Posts













