Johnny Depp Brings Unexpected Heart and Gothic Edge to "Ebenezer"

Kevin Rodriguez • November 19, 2026

Title: Ebenezer

Director: Ti West

Starring: Johnny Depp

Genre: Drama

Studio: Paramount Pictures

Rating: PG-13 (For frightening material)

Do we need another adaptation of Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol? I feel like this is the opening line critics are legally obligated to ask. I mean, what else can you ask of a story that has been adapted (by some estimates) 100 to 400 times across film, TV, animation, and short films—how can you not ask? But over the years, I think that’s the wrong question. After all, isn’t that like asking someone if they actually need dessert after dinner? The answer is, unquestionably, no. However, we all like dessert, which is fun and tasty, and there are a lot of different ways you can have ice cream or cake. And if A Christmas Carol has a special topping, it’s Ebenezer Scrooge.

A person in dark clothing leans over a cluttered workshop table with candles and red blocks, beside tall windows.

Scrooge is one of the greatest literary characters of all time. He is also a gift to actors, because his personality is so layered that most actors are eager to play him and put their own spin on him. Alastair Sim played him as a mean but somewhat aloof figure. Patrick Stewart played him with a strong, Shakespearean stage presence. Personally, my favorite is Michael Caine, who managed to create the most human portrayal of the character (despite working alongside some unusual co-stars). Now, Johnny Depp is the one growling "humbug," giving us what may be a quirkier version of the character, but one with a lot of emotional heart that many may be surprised to discover.

Yes, he hunches over with a snarl. Yes, he says the famous lines. And yes, he has that quirky energy when he delivers some of these lines, because what else do you expect from the guy who created the performance of Captain Jack Sparrow? What surprised me was not only the slow humanity that is discovered in the character, but how unusually apologetic he is (I would normally warn about spoilers here, but… come on, who are we kidding?). While there are many ways to play Scrooge, the one thing no actor can mess up is "the realization." This is the moment where something happens, and Scrooge has a look of understanding on his face, and the audience needs to feel that an epiphany of sorts has happened. If you don’t nail this, then I would argue the whole adaptation falls apart.

A person in a black top hat and dark coat stares wide-eyed with mouth open in a dim interior.

What makes Depp’s moment of clarity work so well is that we actually see minor glimpses of his humanity before the ghosts arrive. An early scene involves Scrooge telling off the charity workers and laughing while making a joke in the direction of his old business partner, Jacob Marley, before he remembers he isn’t there. He has never admitted that Marley was his friend, but for a moment, we can tell that he thought of him in such a way and still hasn’t gotten over his death seven years later. When Scrooge has the impending realization (during a moment I was not expecting), we see that same look on his face. What’s more, the realization comes back near the end, when he discovers he has a new chance to change his life, yet he pauses as he is unsure of where to begin in that process.

A hooded figure looks startled in the dark, holding a small candle aloft.

Ebenezer, in fact, may spend more of its emotional chips on the aftermath of Scrooge’s redemption. The director makes a conscious effort to lean into horror elements during the hauntings—where weird things can happen, and nobody questions why—before shifting focus to the emotional fallout after the fact. This gives Depp the chance to create his unusual version of Scrooge during these sequences and then put his considerable acting talent to proper use once the audience is fully invested in Scrooge’s redemption (spoiler alert).

A pale figure in white holds flowers beside a dark-robed figure wearing a black head covering, in a stone courtyard.

It should be noted that during the visions, the film is dark and gothic, with a weird choice to make the Ghost of Christmas Past more frightening than the Ghost of Christmas Future. Once they are over, we get Depp’s most emotional acting since Finding Neverland, and I was truly impressed with how much emphasis was put on Scrooge’s humbling of himself—something that is normally overlooked in favor of the other characters being so taken aback that he isn’t acting like a jerk anymore. And you know, for all the discussion surrounding Depp (and rightfully so), he is surrounded by great supporting actors like Rupert Grint, Daisy Ridley, Andrea Riseborough, and Sir Freaking Ian McKellen as Jacob Marley, and I want them to be acknowledged in this review as well.

A person in a tall black top hat and dark coat stands on a crowded market street lined with shops.

So do we need another version of Dickens’s story titled Ebenezer? No, we frankly do not. But that doesn’t mean we can’t have fun with another adaptation, and Depp gives us such a unique take on the character that it would have been a shame not to see it. There are issues, as usual. It may be too dark for families (the PG-13 rating is earned), and if you aren’t a fan of Depp’s personal acting quirks, then I don’t think this will change your mind. The story has remained a classic for years for a reason, though, and in a world where kindness is becoming rarer as society puts more emphasis on financial success, it is a great reminder that, in the end, you can’t take money with you and your friends will be where your true worth is measured on your deathbed. Also, for as dark as this gets, at least it isn’t the misfire that the Guy Pearce miniseries was. I don’t know who thought that was a good idea!

Black star on a white background.
Black star on a white background.
Black star on a white background.

3.5 Stars


Blank white image.

Share this page with fellow film lovers on your favorite social media platform and let’s keep the movie talk going!

Recent Posts

A bearded person in a burgundy fur garment examines a small card inside a shop lined with clothing and artwork.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 18, 2026
Jack Black plays Satan in Dear Santa, a hilarious but uneven Christmas comedy that struggles to balance edgy humor with a strained heartfelt holiday message.
A large bearded figure with a colorful sack stands beside a smaller figure on a rooftop beneath a full moon in a snowy city.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 18, 2026
Netflix’s Klaus revives the magic of 2D animation with a colorful, heartfelt Christmas story that deserves to be seen on the big screen (but likely won't).
Superman stands solemnly in a crowd, wearing a dark suit with a red cape, as onlookers watch nearby
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
James Gunn’s Superman brings joy, humor, heart, and humanity back to superhero movies, delivering an uplifting adventure with a hero audiences can believe in.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
Sean Baker’s "Anora" turns a sex worker’s Cinderella romance into a gripping comedy-drama, anchored by Mikey Madison’s phenomenal, star-making performance.
Two cartoon tiger cubs surfing a blue wave under a sunny sky
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
DreamWorks’ Dog Man delivers kid-friendly laughs with its silly premise, but its crude humor and uneven appeal make it a better fit for streaming than theaters.
Two people sit at a candlelit table, talking in a dim black-and-white room.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 15, 2026
In Fatherland, director Academy Award-nominated director Paweł Pawlikowski explores the haunting post World War II journey of author Thomas Mann and his daughter .
Two people sit at a small table in a neon-lit, rainy room, facing a hooded figure in the foreground.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 14, 2026
Death Note delivers a thrilling supernatural chase, but its streamlined American adaptation sacrifices much of the moral complexity that made the manga special.
Close-up of a smiling black-and-white cartoon cat face with large eyes and whiskers
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 13, 2026
Bill Hader brings energy and heart to "The Cat in the Hat," but an overstuffed story makes this Dr. Seuss adaptation more exhausting than fun for families.
Silhouetted person gazing through a spacecraft window at Earth and clouds in blue light
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 13, 2026
Netflix’s surprise release The Cloverfield Paradox was a major movie event, but this ambitious sci-fi thriller ultimately fails to deliver on its intriguing premise.
Two people embracing closely in a dark, blue-lit scene, one in a black leather jacket.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 13, 2026
Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams deliver powerful performances in Blue Valentine, a heartbreaking look at love, marriage, and how relationships fall apart.
A bearded person in a burgundy fur garment examines a small card inside a shop lined with clothing and artwork.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 18, 2026
Jack Black plays Satan in Dear Santa, a hilarious but uneven Christmas comedy that struggles to balance edgy humor with a strained heartfelt holiday message.
A large bearded figure with a colorful sack stands beside a smaller figure on a rooftop beneath a full moon in a snowy city.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 18, 2026
Netflix’s Klaus revives the magic of 2D animation with a colorful, heartfelt Christmas story that deserves to be seen on the big screen (but likely won't).
Superman stands solemnly in a crowd, wearing a dark suit with a red cape, as onlookers watch nearby
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
James Gunn’s Superman brings joy, humor, heart, and humanity back to superhero movies, delivering an uplifting adventure with a hero audiences can believe in.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
Sean Baker’s "Anora" turns a sex worker’s Cinderella romance into a gripping comedy-drama, anchored by Mikey Madison’s phenomenal, star-making performance.
Two cartoon tiger cubs surfing a blue wave under a sunny sky
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
DreamWorks’ Dog Man delivers kid-friendly laughs with its silly premise, but its crude humor and uneven appeal make it a better fit for streaming than theaters.
Two people sit at a candlelit table, talking in a dim black-and-white room.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 15, 2026
In Fatherland, director Academy Award-nominated director Paweł Pawlikowski explores the haunting post World War II journey of author Thomas Mann and his daughter .
Two people sit at a small table in a neon-lit, rainy room, facing a hooded figure in the foreground.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 14, 2026
Death Note delivers a thrilling supernatural chase, but its streamlined American adaptation sacrifices much of the moral complexity that made the manga special.
Close-up of a smiling black-and-white cartoon cat face with large eyes and whiskers
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 13, 2026
Bill Hader brings energy and heart to "The Cat in the Hat," but an overstuffed story makes this Dr. Seuss adaptation more exhausting than fun for families.
Silhouetted person gazing through a spacecraft window at Earth and clouds in blue light
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 13, 2026
Netflix’s surprise release The Cloverfield Paradox was a major movie event, but this ambitious sci-fi thriller ultimately fails to deliver on its intriguing premise.
Two people embracing closely in a dark, blue-lit scene, one in a black leather jacket.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 13, 2026
Ryan Gosling and Michelle Williams deliver powerful performances in Blue Valentine, a heartbreaking look at love, marriage, and how relationships fall apart.
Show More