"The Amazing Spider-Man" Review

Sean Dollentas • September 5, 2025

Title: The Amazing Spider-Man

Director: Marc Webb

In 2002 “Spider-Man” burst onto the movie screen and brought superhero movies to mainstream audiences in a way that had never been done before. With huge box office results and critical acclaim, for the first time since Tim Burton directed “Batman” had a comic book movie been so successful. That was ten years ago. Since then we've gotten so many superhero movies that some people have called them modern day Greek mythology stories. Now that we've gotten a re-telling of Spider-Man's origin story in “The Amazing Spider-Man” I have to wonder if that now makes superheroes like classic literature. I mean, think about it: how many versions of “Hamlet” have you seen? Never mind.

Spider-Man swings through a city, red and blue suit, holding a web.

Most of you likely won't be pondering this as you sit down in a dark movie theater to watch “The Amazing Spider-Man.” For many of you it will simply be a new superhero movie (and the first in 3D for this franchise) to go see. I admit, as much as I loved “The Avengers” for its goofy action sequences and non-stop fun, it's nice to see a superhero movie that can be taken seriously on a truly thoughtful level again. For those who saw Sam Raimi's take on the character in 2002 you won't be too surprised at the storyline, which largely recounts Peter Parker's (Andrew Garfield) coming to grips with his super powers and dealing with the death of his Uncle Ben (Martin Sheen), what he could have prevented if he wanted to.

Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield lean together by lockers in a school hallway.

That we're going through this again is frustrating, but understanding since the studio wants to create a new series of Spider-Man movies. What is new here is a new love interest named Gwen Stacy (Emma Thompson), who is a long way from the red haired Mary Jane. Gwen is a smart scientist who has an eye for smart boys with a heart of gold. If you've had complaints that most of the love interests in these types of movies have little reason to exist outside of being saved, then you're going to love Gwen Stacy's resources that aid Spider-Man in some of the very intense battles in this film. And who is Spider-Man facing in this film?

Family at a dining table

Well, it's a scientist named Dr. Curt Connors (Rhys Ifans), whose medical experiments cause him to transform into The Lizard, a creator who comes close to coming off as fake, but honestly it's hard to tell with the action moving so fast. The best new character in this film is probably Captain George Stacy, played with shocking conviction by comedian Dennis Leary, who gives this minor character some real depth. Captain Stacy is out to arrest both Spider-Man and The Lizard, but he is a smart, cautious man. He takes in the situation as he best sees fit, and isn't too proud to change tactics when he realizes he's made a mistake. Despite the trouble he causes our hero we can't hate him because we empathize with him.

Spider-Man sits on a dark floor, facing away. Red and blue suit, with a red mask visible.

If there is one truly credible reason to reboot the series so soon it would be the visual effects. Not only does Spider-Man move with much more realistic fluidity in this film, but the natural use of 3D gives you one of the rare “out-of-body experiences” that only the biggest screen can provide. The IMAX 3D version offers a visual experience on par with “Avatar” and “How to Train Your Dragon.” The fact that it can present material we've already seen a mere ten years ago and make it seem fresh makes “The Amazing Spider-Man” all the more impressive. Why, it even works as a classic love story at times to boot! If you decide you want to see your favorite web slinger on the big screen again, “The Amazing Spider-Man” is a worthy remake. See it on the biggest screen you can.

Black star on a white background.
Black star on a white background.
Black star on a white background.
Black star on white background.

4 Rating


Empty white background.

Share this page with fellow film lovers on your favorite social media platform and let’s keep the movie talk going!

Recent Posts

Airplane flying through dark storm clouds overhead
By Kevin Rodriguez September 16, 2026
A gripping look at the events aboard United Flight 93, iCritic's review explores how Greengrass's film powerfully captures the fear, courage, and chaos of 9/11.
Dimly lit lounge with neon arch lights, people seated at tables, and a bright windowed area on the left.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 11, 2026
Disney’s Star Wars hotel promised an immersive revolution but became a costly failure—revealing the hubris behind one of Disney’s biggest miscalculations in history.
Two men face off in a dry field; one raises a hand while holding a shotgun.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 9, 2026
Does the Coen brothers' "No Country for Old Men" live up to its massive hype? Read our full review exploring Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin, and that shocking ending.
Superhero team standing amid rubble, with Captain America, Iron Man, Hulk, Thor and others ready for battle
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Does Marvel's epic team-up live up to the hype? Read iCritic's full review of "The Avengers" exploring Joss Whedon's witty dialogue, Loki, and non-stop action.
Menacing black robot head with glowing red eyes against a cloudy sky
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Overstuffed action and zero stakes make "Avengers: Age of Ultron" a major disappointment. Read iCritic's (borderline frustrated) review of Joss Whedon's MCU sequel.
Thanos in gold armor raises his gauntlet amid a fiery battle scene
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Is "Avengers: Infinity War" a true cinematic epic or half a movie? Read our full unrated review exploring Josh Brolin's Thanos and Marvel's boldest cliffhanger.
Person crouches in a dim teal-lit industrial room, working with equipment amid cables and machinery.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
It all comes together in ‘Avengers: Endgame,’ as Marvel delivers an emotional, action-packed culmination of more than a decade of storytelling in the popular MCU.
Person holding Captain America shield outdoors on a grassy field with trees in the background
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
“Captain America: Brave New World” struggles to find its footing, delivering a disappointing Marvel sequel that feels more ordinary than brave, bold, or new.
Close-up of a man’s face beside a glowing silhouetted figure on a dark orange background
By Kevin Rodriguez August 27, 2026
More than just an iconic twist: Read iCritic's review of "The Sixth Sense" to see why Bruce Willis & Haley Joel Osment's ghost story remains a heartbreaking classic
Black-and-white portrait of a stern-faced person with dramatic spiky hair against a dark background
By Kevin Rodriguez August 27, 2026
Bizarre, hypnotic, and morbidly beautiful: Read iCritic's 3.5-star review of David Lynch's directorial debut "Eraserhead" and its lasting surreal horror legacy.
Airplane flying through dark storm clouds overhead
By Kevin Rodriguez September 16, 2026
A gripping look at the events aboard United Flight 93, iCritic's review explores how Greengrass's film powerfully captures the fear, courage, and chaos of 9/11.
Dimly lit lounge with neon arch lights, people seated at tables, and a bright windowed area on the left.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 11, 2026
Disney’s Star Wars hotel promised an immersive revolution but became a costly failure—revealing the hubris behind one of Disney’s biggest miscalculations in history.
Two men face off in a dry field; one raises a hand while holding a shotgun.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 9, 2026
Does the Coen brothers' "No Country for Old Men" live up to its massive hype? Read our full review exploring Javier Bardem, Josh Brolin, and that shocking ending.
Superhero team standing amid rubble, with Captain America, Iron Man, Hulk, Thor and others ready for battle
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Does Marvel's epic team-up live up to the hype? Read iCritic's full review of "The Avengers" exploring Joss Whedon's witty dialogue, Loki, and non-stop action.
Menacing black robot head with glowing red eyes against a cloudy sky
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Overstuffed action and zero stakes make "Avengers: Age of Ultron" a major disappointment. Read iCritic's (borderline frustrated) review of Joss Whedon's MCU sequel.
Thanos in gold armor raises his gauntlet amid a fiery battle scene
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
Is "Avengers: Infinity War" a true cinematic epic or half a movie? Read our full unrated review exploring Josh Brolin's Thanos and Marvel's boldest cliffhanger.
Person crouches in a dim teal-lit industrial room, working with equipment amid cables and machinery.
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
It all comes together in ‘Avengers: Endgame,’ as Marvel delivers an emotional, action-packed culmination of more than a decade of storytelling in the popular MCU.
Person holding Captain America shield outdoors on a grassy field with trees in the background
By Kevin Rodriguez September 3, 2026
“Captain America: Brave New World” struggles to find its footing, delivering a disappointing Marvel sequel that feels more ordinary than brave, bold, or new.
Close-up of a man’s face beside a glowing silhouetted figure on a dark orange background
By Kevin Rodriguez August 27, 2026
More than just an iconic twist: Read iCritic's review of "The Sixth Sense" to see why Bruce Willis & Haley Joel Osment's ghost story remains a heartbreaking classic
Black-and-white portrait of a stern-faced person with dramatic spiky hair against a dark background
By Kevin Rodriguez August 27, 2026
Bizarre, hypnotic, and morbidly beautiful: Read iCritic's 3.5-star review of David Lynch's directorial debut "Eraserhead" and its lasting surreal horror legacy.
Show More