Pixar’s "Onward" Promises Magic but Delivers a Predictable Adventure

Kevin Rodriguez • November 20, 2026

Title: Onward

Director: Dan Scanlon

Starring: Tom Holland, Chris Pratt, Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Octavia Spencer

Genre: Fantasy

Studio: Pixar

Rating: PG (For action/peril and some mild thematic elements)

Note: This review was originally written in 2020. Except for cleaning it up for grammatical errors, it is being republished as it was originally written.


I've been sitting at my computer for a good while, afraid to write this review. I sort of feel like the critic from Brad Bird's Ratatouille, contemplating the purpose of his life's work and admitting there are risks in stepping out on a limb. I feel that I will be stepping out on a limb with my review for Onward—the latest Pixar film—because it does pretty much everything I've wanted from a Pixar film in years... and yet I'm still not happy. Some of you may scoff at why such a thing would bother me, but it really can hurt your ego a bit. Here I've been, writing positive (but lukewarm) reviews for the last several Pixar films. I bemoaned the fact that Toy Story 4 felt pointless (as well as complained when it won the Oscar over the far better Klaus). I shrugged off Incredibles 2 as a fun but meaningless affair. I'm still not sure why Finding Dory was made other than to give Andrew Stanton a hit movie after John Carter bombed.

Three animated trolls sit on a wooden bench indoors, with a window and warm-toned furnishings behind them.

Throughout all those reviews, I hoped, pleaded, and practically begged for Pixar to give me another original film like the good old days. Now they have given me Onward, an original movie with a unique concept. And as I sat in the theater watching it, I found myself bored and perplexed by what I was watching. On one hand, you had a unique setup where wizards, elves, and griffins no longer used magic because heating up food was dangerous and the microwave could do it so much better. I liked that idea. On the other hand, once I realized I would mostly be watching a movie with fantastical creatures doing very suburban things, I felt shortchanged by the very same concept that was initially cool. I really liked the idea that two boys cast a spell to bring their dead father back from the grave for one day. I was more than frustrated when the spell got botched, forcing the two leads to interact with a pair of legs (seriously, it's just one step above the idiocy of Weekend at Bernie's).

The animation... alright, I have no problems with the animation. It's beautiful to behold, and I maintain that whatever the animators are getting paid to create these worlds, it simply isn't enough. Though, again, as I sat watching the movie, I was confused as to why the animators weren't making use of the fantastic creatures they designed. By the end, everything ended up feeling very by-the-numbers despite how creative the world was, and thus I felt robbed of what promised to be an emotional journey. The movie is directed by Dan Scanlon, whose previous directorial job was Monsters University. That movie made far more use out of the unique monsters that were created; however, I must note that it was a prequel to Monsters, Inc., and thus got a lot of use out of the memorable cast that director/writer Pete Docter brought to that project. Taking both films into account, I'm going to lean toward saying Scanlon does well when he's playing with someone else's toys, but has yet to master the art of creating compelling toys of his own.

A large, smiling man and a worried young person stand on a muddy roadside, holding a trident-like staff beside a parked car.

In this case, the toys are the characters, and in Onward, the main characters are two elves named Ian (Tom Holland) and Barley (Chris Pratt), both of whom grew up in a fantasy world where no one uses magic anymore because technology is easier and safer. It's a world where a centaur will drive a car over galloping, unicorns act more like stray cats than majestic beings, and a tavern once owned by the fiercest adventurer in all the land has been converted into a family restaurant that reminds us more of Chuck E. Cheese than what you would find in the taverns on Game of Thrones. As you look objectively at these situations, you can appreciate the idea behind them, yet you are frustrated that you are essentially watching a fantasy world that (by design) is lazy and milquetoast. The world is so milquetoast, in fact, that the boys are surprised to find a staff left behind by their father, complete with a spell that would bring him back to life for one day.

A muscular toy-like figure confronts a colorful, green-haired character in a cluttered workshop with arched windows.

Ian never even met his father, so this was a strong setup. Sadly, the spell is botched, and the only part of him they manage to bring back is his two legs, forcing them to go on a quest to find a crystal to bring the rest of him back for the remainder of the day. This is where I started to lose it. I know this is a movie made for families, but Pixar has never been one to shy away from bleak realities and heart-crushing moments. I feel that a movie where the two boys actually get to spend a real day with their deceased dad would have opened the door to so many possibilities. How would he react to them? Would Ian like his dad? Would their dad react poorly to what has become of the world? So many wasted opportunities. And for what? Another buddy road comedy that Pixar built its studio upon (and has made better in the past)?

Two animated characters stand in a grassy clearing at night beside a pair of legs protruding from the ground.

I mean... to the film's credit, this isn't a bad film by any stretch! I just find it terribly uninteresting, and I ended up enjoying what my imagination came up with better. That's not what Pixar films do. Pixar worlds literally pull you into the environments they create. They take you to places you've never been and make you feel emotions you don't expect to. The ending has a little of that, but is that enough when the movie opens by promising you Disneyland and ends up giving you Knott's Berry Farm? I don't know—maybe on another day I would have been more sucked into this. I will certainly give it credit for not being a sequel. However, Onward gives us all the predictable story tropes they mastered in the past, all while holding back a magical experience right before our eyes. Call me difficult to please, but if their heart isn't in it, I'd rather they work on a soulless cash grab.

Black star on a white background.
Black star on a white background.
Solid black five-pointed star with rounded edges on a white background.

2.5 Stars


Blank white image.

Share this page with fellow film lovers on your favorite social media platform and let’s keep the movie talk going!

Recent Posts

A wide-eyed doll-like figure sits in a red coat inside a swirling tunnel of blue and purple fabric.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 20, 2026
Laika’s Coraline returns in a stunning 4K 3D restoration, proving that imaginative stop-motion animation and genuinely scary storytelling never go out of style.
A stern-looking person in a black top hat and coat stands before a large brass-rimmed clock.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 19, 2026
Johnny Depp brings unexpected heart and gothic quirks to Ebenezer Scrooge in this dark, emotionally rich take on A Christmas Carol (just leave the kids at home).
A bearded person in a burgundy fur garment examines a small card inside a shop lined with clothing and artwork.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 18, 2026
Jack Black plays Satan in Dear Santa, a hilarious but uneven Christmas comedy that struggles to balance edgy humor with a strained heartfelt holiday message.
A large bearded figure with a colorful sack stands beside a smaller figure on a rooftop beneath a full moon in a snowy city.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 18, 2026
Netflix’s Klaus revives the magic of 2D animation with a colorful, heartfelt Christmas story that deserves to be seen on the big screen (but likely won't).
Superman stands solemnly in a crowd, wearing a dark suit with a red cape, as onlookers watch nearby
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
James Gunn’s Superman brings joy, humor, heart, and humanity back to superhero movies, delivering an uplifting adventure with a hero audiences can believe in.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
Sean Baker’s "Anora" turns a sex worker’s Cinderella romance into a gripping comedy-drama, anchored by Mikey Madison’s phenomenal, star-making performance.
Two cartoon tiger cubs surfing a blue wave under a sunny sky
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
DreamWorks’ Dog Man delivers kid-friendly laughs with its silly premise, but its crude humor and uneven appeal make it a better fit for streaming than theaters.
Two people sit at a candlelit table, talking in a dim black-and-white room.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 15, 2026
In Fatherland, director Academy Award-nominated director Paweł Pawlikowski explores the haunting post World War II journey of author Thomas Mann and his daughter .
Two people sit at a small table in a neon-lit, rainy room, facing a hooded figure in the foreground.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 14, 2026
Death Note delivers a thrilling supernatural chase, but its streamlined American adaptation sacrifices much of the moral complexity that made the manga special.
Close-up of a smiling black-and-white cartoon cat face with large eyes and whiskers
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 13, 2026
Bill Hader brings energy and heart to "The Cat in the Hat," but an overstuffed story makes this Dr. Seuss adaptation more exhausting than fun for families.
A wide-eyed doll-like figure sits in a red coat inside a swirling tunnel of blue and purple fabric.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 20, 2026
Laika’s Coraline returns in a stunning 4K 3D restoration, proving that imaginative stop-motion animation and genuinely scary storytelling never go out of style.
A stern-looking person in a black top hat and coat stands before a large brass-rimmed clock.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 19, 2026
Johnny Depp brings unexpected heart and gothic quirks to Ebenezer Scrooge in this dark, emotionally rich take on A Christmas Carol (just leave the kids at home).
A bearded person in a burgundy fur garment examines a small card inside a shop lined with clothing and artwork.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 18, 2026
Jack Black plays Satan in Dear Santa, a hilarious but uneven Christmas comedy that struggles to balance edgy humor with a strained heartfelt holiday message.
A large bearded figure with a colorful sack stands beside a smaller figure on a rooftop beneath a full moon in a snowy city.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 18, 2026
Netflix’s Klaus revives the magic of 2D animation with a colorful, heartfelt Christmas story that deserves to be seen on the big screen (but likely won't).
Superman stands solemnly in a crowd, wearing a dark suit with a red cape, as onlookers watch nearby
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
James Gunn’s Superman brings joy, humor, heart, and humanity back to superhero movies, delivering an uplifting adventure with a hero audiences can believe in.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
Sean Baker’s "Anora" turns a sex worker’s Cinderella romance into a gripping comedy-drama, anchored by Mikey Madison’s phenomenal, star-making performance.
Two cartoon tiger cubs surfing a blue wave under a sunny sky
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 16, 2026
DreamWorks’ Dog Man delivers kid-friendly laughs with its silly premise, but its crude humor and uneven appeal make it a better fit for streaming than theaters.
Two people sit at a candlelit table, talking in a dim black-and-white room.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 15, 2026
In Fatherland, director Academy Award-nominated director Paweł Pawlikowski explores the haunting post World War II journey of author Thomas Mann and his daughter .
Two people sit at a small table in a neon-lit, rainy room, facing a hooded figure in the foreground.
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 14, 2026
Death Note delivers a thrilling supernatural chase, but its streamlined American adaptation sacrifices much of the moral complexity that made the manga special.
Close-up of a smiling black-and-white cartoon cat face with large eyes and whiskers
By Kevin Rodriguez • November 13, 2026
Bill Hader brings energy and heart to "The Cat in the Hat," but an overstuffed story makes this Dr. Seuss adaptation more exhausting than fun for families.
Show More