"17 Again" Movie Review by Kevin Rodriguez

Sean Dollentas • August 6, 2025

Title: 17 Again 

Director: Burr Steers 

Starring: Zac Efron 

We all dream of what we would do if we could go back to being a kid again but what if you actually got that opportunity? Mike O’Donnell (Matthew Perry) is in both boats. Having given up a potential NBA career to marry his impregnated girlfriend at the age of 17 he’s finding himself regretting that decision. Not that we totally blame him. At 37 he’s lost a promotion, is in the middle of a bitter divorce, and his kids don’t want anything to do with him. Then one day an old janitor grants Mike his wish and makes him “17 Again.” Although Mike may be 17 now (and looking a lot like “High School Musical” star Zac Efron) he has in no way time traveled. He’s still in the present day just younger, and now he has the chance to make things work.

Woman and man, smiling, stand on a balcony

He signs up to be in the high school his kids are in (so he can keep an eye on them), he works on getting the basketball scholarship he’s always wanted, and he gets the chance to be popular once more. But what am I telling you all this for? This is a committee film, made to be very carefully calculated for the widest possible audience possible. This would be a good film so long as it wasn’t lousy. Even so, this is a pretty enjoyable little film. Touching even at some points. We’ve seen this type of movie before, but most of the time it’s the kid who wants to be older. While there is little advantage to growing old before your time the idea of getting younger has it’s distinct advantages.

Two men in a school hallway face each other.

But growing younger in a generation you don’t understand? That would present some challenges in itself. At one point Mike has a heart-to-heart conversation with his ex-wife, and she spills all the things about her life that he made miserable. He wants to comfort her, but how does he properly do that? For that matter, what do you do when you drive away the bad boyfriend that’s dating your daughter only to have her get the hots for you? These scenes are predictable and are almost required for this sort of movie, but they are played out carefully enough where they have more of an emotional payoff instead of just a cheap laugh or two. Much has been of the fact that Zac Efron is making his first PG-13 film that’s not distributed by Disney.

Woman in green and young woman in purple walking in a gymnasium.

I have to admit that despite myself the kid is very likable in this film. Will he go on to have a big career? Maybe. A career he will have, but right now I’m thinking this movie will be for him what “Ferris Bueller’s Day Off” was for Matthew Broderick. Though forgettable “17 Again” sets out to be a charming mid-life crisis film and succeeds at being just that. Though it won’t be up for any Oscars or great acclaim, this is an easy film to recommend for the young and the young at heart.

Black star on a white background.
Black star on a white background.
Black star on a white background.
Black star on a white background.
Black star shape on the left side of white background.

4.5  Rating


Blank white image.

Share this page with fellow film lovers on your favorite social media platform and let’s keep the movie talk going!

Recent Posts

Speed Racer drives the Mach 6.
By Kevin Rodriguez April 22, 2026
“Speed Racer” explodes with color, chaos, and candy‑coated energy. iCritic explores how this cinematic acid trip became a bold, misunderstood cult favorite.
Animated scene featuring Aang, Katara, Zuko, Sokka, and Toph from Avatar: The Last Airbender.
By Kevin Rodriguez April 14, 2026
A major leak of the new Avatar film is stirring panic among fans and studios alike, prompting fears that the franchise’s momentum and future may be in jeopardy.
Arthur Fleck, as the Joker, stands before a mirror with
By Kevin Rodriguez April 5, 2026
Exploring the torment beneath the Joker’s iconic grin, "Joker" explores how trauma, neglect, and fractured identity fuel the darkness behind his haunting smile.
Joker and Harley Quinn stand face-to-face in a spotlight on a balcony, illuminated against a dark, red-lit background.
By Kevin Rodriguez April 5, 2026
In “Joker: Folie à Deux” Arthur Fleck sings his way through madness and obsession, creating a surreal musical sequel that blurs fantasy and reality. iCritic reviews.
Mario, Luigi, and Princess Peach fly through space with a green Yoshi against a vibrant, star-filled nebula background.
By Kevin Rodriguez April 2, 2026
"The Super Mario Galaxy Movie" looks gorgeous but lacks substance. iCritic's review dives into why stunning visuals and fan service can't save a hollow plot.
Batman and Superman stand face-to-face in a close-up, dramatic shot under rainy, dark lighting.
By Kevin Rodriguez March 31, 2026
Ten years on, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice continues to polarize fans and critics, standing as one of the most debated films in modern superhero history.
Llama in a green basketball jersey stands in a stadium, smiling. Purple and white lights illuminate the arena.
By Kevin Rodriguez February 16, 2026
iCritic that admits “GOAT” isn’t top-tier but still celebrates its charm, energy, and entertainment value while highlighting why it works despite its flaws.
Melania Trump in a black suit smiles, standing near a window with the White House in the background.
By Kevin Rodriguez February 3, 2026
iCritic reviews “Melania,” calling it a dull, unfocused documentary that offers little insight or purpose despite its (supposed) unprecedented access and hype.
Chris Pratt sits strapped to a medical chair, looking concerned in a sterile room.
By Kevin Rodriguez January 24, 2026
iCritic’s review of Mercy examines how the film puts artificial intelligence on trial, blending dumb courtroom drama with timely questions about technology.
Man smiling, wearing glasses, holding a US flag, surrounded by people with flags.
By Kevin Rodriguez January 10, 2026
iCritic reviews “Marty Supreme,” breaking down how its frantic pacing, abrasive tone, and shallow characters make the film an exhausting and unlikable experience.
Speed Racer drives the Mach 6.
By Kevin Rodriguez April 22, 2026
“Speed Racer” explodes with color, chaos, and candy‑coated energy. iCritic explores how this cinematic acid trip became a bold, misunderstood cult favorite.
Animated scene featuring Aang, Katara, Zuko, Sokka, and Toph from Avatar: The Last Airbender.
By Kevin Rodriguez April 14, 2026
A major leak of the new Avatar film is stirring panic among fans and studios alike, prompting fears that the franchise’s momentum and future may be in jeopardy.
Arthur Fleck, as the Joker, stands before a mirror with
By Kevin Rodriguez April 5, 2026
Exploring the torment beneath the Joker’s iconic grin, "Joker" explores how trauma, neglect, and fractured identity fuel the darkness behind his haunting smile.
Joker and Harley Quinn stand face-to-face in a spotlight on a balcony, illuminated against a dark, red-lit background.
By Kevin Rodriguez April 5, 2026
In “Joker: Folie à Deux” Arthur Fleck sings his way through madness and obsession, creating a surreal musical sequel that blurs fantasy and reality. iCritic reviews.
Mario, Luigi, and Princess Peach fly through space with a green Yoshi against a vibrant, star-filled nebula background.
By Kevin Rodriguez April 2, 2026
"The Super Mario Galaxy Movie" looks gorgeous but lacks substance. iCritic's review dives into why stunning visuals and fan service can't save a hollow plot.
Batman and Superman stand face-to-face in a close-up, dramatic shot under rainy, dark lighting.
By Kevin Rodriguez March 31, 2026
Ten years on, Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice continues to polarize fans and critics, standing as one of the most debated films in modern superhero history.
Llama in a green basketball jersey stands in a stadium, smiling. Purple and white lights illuminate the arena.
By Kevin Rodriguez February 16, 2026
iCritic that admits “GOAT” isn’t top-tier but still celebrates its charm, energy, and entertainment value while highlighting why it works despite its flaws.
Melania Trump in a black suit smiles, standing near a window with the White House in the background.
By Kevin Rodriguez February 3, 2026
iCritic reviews “Melania,” calling it a dull, unfocused documentary that offers little insight or purpose despite its (supposed) unprecedented access and hype.
Chris Pratt sits strapped to a medical chair, looking concerned in a sterile room.
By Kevin Rodriguez January 24, 2026
iCritic’s review of Mercy examines how the film puts artificial intelligence on trial, blending dumb courtroom drama with timely questions about technology.
Man smiling, wearing glasses, holding a US flag, surrounded by people with flags.
By Kevin Rodriguez January 10, 2026
iCritic reviews “Marty Supreme,” breaking down how its frantic pacing, abrasive tone, and shallow characters make the film an exhausting and unlikable experience.
Show More